Ok, if you happen to read this out on the podcast, just call me Gummi (yes, like the Gummi Bears. Apparently 'Drekafluga' is not a good name on DA). o_Q
WoW, hands down. Yes, the physical embodiment of your money is more evident in the 360 but when it comes down to it, I suspect that I would end up spending more hours playing WoW than all the games I'd get for the 360 combined.
I feel the question items here are interchangeable with other games / consoles for the same amount of money. I guess what I'm trying to say is that I'd rather have a single great game subscription than the means to buy potentially great games for more money and then having to agonize over which ones to choose.
Really? just WoW or a 360? At least with WoW, you know you'll have a chance it won't RROD on you. Besides, I got out of WoW last year because it served it's purpose for 4+ years of me playing it. I needed something new other than leveling another alt because I hated to just join a PUG raid. I was in a guild for 2 years before that and my schedule never let me be able to be on time for the raids they planned.
After playing the STO beta, I think it would be my replacement MMO for WoW. It didn't require the game to act like a job... doing quests in the game didn't feel like grinding all that much. It felt like playing a Space sim within Star Trek. Money didn't have to be farmed for anything.